De-Humanizing the Job Search

Spend about 30 seconds (or less) perusing the latestelement.
job search advice, and you will no doubt come acrossUnlike selling cars or the latest pharmaceutical drug, in
statements like the following:this case, the seller must play two roles: (1) as the
"A job search is nothing more than a marketingsales rep. who is selling themselves (2) as the
campaign with you being the product."product. So if job seekers aren't careful, either they
"An effective job seeker in today's marketare too good at either being the product or too good
understands the power of personal branding."at being the seller (or just plain too good at making
"A job seeker is a sales professional; the morethemselves sound like the latest and greatest new
nuanced the pitch, the more effective the result."brand of toothpaste), but either way, they end up
As a career pro who has participated in establishingtrapped in some weird kind of brand awareness
this line of thinking, I certainly can nod my head incampaign that has them exhausted and discouraged
agreement with these sentiments.and often achieving negligible results. And has hiring
Yes, the job search process is definitely a salesmanagers wondering whether it is a full moon and all
process, and yes, you are essentially the "product"the aliens have landed.
that is being sold. So it stands to reason that you areWhy? Because people aren't staplers. They're much
positioning that product when you are out theremore complex than that. And their target market is
presenting yourself to potential employers.also made up of people who aren't just looking at
So why if I agree with these sentiments, do theythem like objects to fulfill a job function for the
make me cringe so much when I hear someonebetterment of the company. Sure, it may start out
express them?that way when they post the position opening, but
Maybe it's because I can't stop thinking about cattleonce they get candidates in front of them, they
whenever I hear the word "branding" or about humandon't necessarily want to be "sold" to at every turn;
trafficking whenever I start thinking of job seekersthey want to believe they can build a relationship
as "products" to be auctioned off to the highestwith you, the person.
bidder.In other words, they are real people who want to
I know, call me sentimental. Maybe I'm a bleedingtalk to other real people. They're not interested in
heart, after all. But although I certainly agree with thepersonal brands and products.
statements above, in theory, it's the application thatSo what is a job seeker to do? "Sell" yourself? Yes.
often comes off a little stale to me."Position" yourself? Yes. But along the way, don't lose
Listen. You can't play the game without a program,sight of the fact that at the end of all this
right? And without a doubt, this job search game isstrategizing, it comes down to a small group of
played best when the primary aspects of ahuman beings who want another human being to fill a
successful sales lifecycle are recognized and, to someneed but often just as importantly blend in with
extent, implemented.them, coexist each day in a very real way. They're
Yet to leave it at that and wash your hands of thenot buying a TV, after all.
discussion misses a crucial element: the human