How Do We Account for Instinct?

There are two basic types of intelligence. One isHere is what we have learned: Monarchs spend
prepackaged, ready-made kind of know-how whichsummers as far north as the Great Lakes and
we call instinct. Fish, insects, amphibians, and reptilesCanada. As the summer turns to fall, large loosely
all appear to operate on this level. They do whatformed groups begin massing for southern migration.
they are programmed to do, and that is about allButterflies with wings no larger than four inches fly
they can do.up to two thousand mile to southern California,
At the other end of the spectrum we find humans.central Mexico, or Florida for the winter.
People are endowed with free-lance, independentEn route, the same trees are chosen as resting
intelligence which allows us to make our ownplaces every year. Of course none of the insects
decisions. In between are an assortment of mammalshave seen these trees before. Yet they land en
which use a mixture of instinct and "thinking" to onemasse on the same branches generation after
degree or another. Cows, horses, cats, dogs, pigs,generation, migration after migration.
monkeys, and dolphins all fit into this broad category.Pacific Grove, California is winter home for many,
Honeybeesmaybe most, west coast monarchs. The whole town
Instinct tends to complicate the picture foris a refuge for the species. In fact, it is one of the
naturalists. Take the honeybee for instance. Like allfew insect sanctuaries in the world. During the month
other insects, this bee is little more than aof October, several million monarch butterflies begin
programmed robot. Yet, at the same time, itarriving in this coastal town overlooking the Monterey
possesses a highly specialized instinct. It is anBay. They stay until March.
instinctive engineer with a good deal of expertise inSome monarchs go elsewhere. On the Monterey
honeycomb production.peninsula, pockets of smaller concentrations are
Using 1.4 ounces of wax, bees developfound. But the vast majority congregate year after
hexagonal-cells built to a thickness of 0.073 mm withyear in the same pines in the same grove. The grove
a tolerance of plus or minus 0.002 mm. This minimumitself is nothing but a few acres of tall pines next to
amount of wax proves adequate for holding fourthe sea.
pounds of honey. Now that is an impressive feat forNevertheless, Pacific Grove has been the wintering
an insect, doubly impressive considering its small brain,spot for monarchs every year since at least 1907,
short life span, and utter lack of training. All in all, thewhen locals started keeping records.
bee's hexagonal-shaped comb is the strongest, mostIn the spring these butterflies return on the northern
space efficient structure they could build.route home where they mate and shortly thereafter
No one claims, unless they are joking, that thedie. Are these the same insects that headed south
honeybee came up with the idea of the hexagonlast fall? Evidently they are. A long-term study with
design. They couldn't. They don't have anthousands of tagged monarchs proved that large
independent ability for making decisions. They just donumbers of these butterflies make the round trip,
what they are programmed to do.some going all the way from Canada to Mexico and
The question is Who or What programmed theback again.
honeybee's construction instinct? Since the honeybeeCuriously enough, the next generation does not make
could not program its own instinct, and everybodythis journey. Nor does the next. During the summer,
agrees that is the case, the only alternative is thattwo or three generations of monarchs live out their
some Outside Source programmed the bee'sshort lives mating and dying. The third or fourth
engineering talent.generation of butterflies emerges out of their
What can be said about this Outside Source? Today,cocoons in late summer.
no scientists can program instinct. We wouldn't evenBy and large these are the ones destined for the
know where to begin. That implies a knowledge andround trip south. Once more, without leaders and
technology far in advance of our own. Obviously, thiswithout any prior experience, millions of monarch
Outside Source knows something of constructionbutterflies will make their way south toward their
too.Pacific Grove winter sanctuary. Year after year,
Evidently, a higher intelligence with engineeringinstinct draws them back to the identical trees where
expertise programmed a bit of his owntheir ancestors passed previous winters.
hexagon-building knowledge into the bee's instinct.It is an interesting story, and it brings up a lot of
Which came first, the honeybee or its instinct? The"why" questions. Let's start off by saying that cold
honeybee's entire existence centers around combweather (or maybe just shortened daylight hours)
construction and honey production. As far as we canmight compel the monarchs south. But why does
tell, that has always been the case. Considering thatPacific Grove attract so many of these seasonal
the bee's instinctive behavior is such an intricate parttravelers? How do they find this California town?
of it's life, chances are very good that whoeverWhy do they stop here rather than continuing
designed the honeybee's body also designed itssouthward? Why do they pick out the same trees
instinct. And both were made at the same time.that their predecessors chose in past years? And
Other Insectswhy do they return north in the spring?
Other insects display home-building instincts too.Monarchs, like honeybees, termites, and wasps, are
Australian termites construct high-rise towers. Somenot capable of independent thought. They don't plan
measure twenty-five feet in height with overhangingthings out. They don't set their own agenda. Every
eaves protecting against heavy rains. Termites inthird or fourth generation responds to a detailed
Africa dig holes as deep as 130 feet seeking water.built-in travelogue. They go to Pacific Grove because
Wasp build homes out of paper, and ants tunnel outthat is the place they are programmed to go.
complex underground homes. All of these insectsThey head north for the same reason. But Who or
depend upon an ingrained architectural instinct, a bitWhat designed this travel program? Again, since the
of programmed wisdom by the Outside Source.programmed instinct did not originate with the
One form of instinct we are all familiar with ismonarch, it had to come from an external source.
migration. Mention migration and flocks of ducks orThat Outside Source shows both biological and
geese come to mind. Usually we think of them in ageographical knowledge. What's more, this Outsider
rough "V" formation where one leg is shorter thanmust have a remarkably advanced technology to
the other. But other animals migrate too - fish, whale,implant such a thorough migration program into the
and insects. Insects? Yes, insects do migrate. C.C.tiny brain of a butterfly.
Williams, a British entomologist, listed some 250The honeybee's engineering talent, the termite and
migrating insects.wasp's architectural skills, and the monarch butterfly's
Monarch Butterfliesdetailed, persistent travel itinerary are more than just
In general we can say, populations of insects makeinteresting tidbits of nature. Each show an area of
migratory movements, heading south in early fall andexpertise far beyond what any short-lived,
north the next spring. Individuals probably die in route.microscopic-brained insect could achieve on its own.
That being the case, it is their offspring that continueThey had help. An Outside Source supplied them with
the round trip. Our information is spotty on mostspecific knowledge to perform specific tasks. What
species, so, much of what we are told is little morewe call instinct is, in fact, a bit of wisdom
than guesswork on insect migration. There is anprogrammed by the Outside Source.
exception, however. That exception is perhaps theEvolutionists offer no explanation for instinct. They
most popular insect of all - the monarch butterfly.usually avoid the subject.