Immigration & Integration

Having lived in the United Kingdom for over 40 years,generally they complain frequently about the
I saw wave after wave of immigration from Asia,Portuguese language, the Madeiran way of driving,
mainly India and Pakistan in the early days, followedand the fact they can’t get certain products
by Europeans coming as the barriers for movementthey used to get in their previous lives, and for sure
within Europe were relaxed and new memberthey are not going to try and learn to speak
countries entered into the European Union, oftenPortuguese. It is not my intention to be disrespectful
facilitated by new innovations in cheap travel andto these people, as they have made their own
vastly improved communications, and informationchoices, as they have every right to do.
resources available through internet developments.So I made a conscious decision to integrate, followed
In the UK I had several Asian friends, partly throughby an enormous effort to do so, starting with
the oddity that we used the same swimming poollearning to speak Portuguese. It’s probably the
and sauna at the same times and days, and I hadhardest thing I have ever tried to learn in my life, and
other friends from ethnic minority groups, mainlylong after those initial encouraging comments like
through the fact that I made the effort to speak to‘it takes 10 years to learn’ and ‘you will
people I saw often or passed on a regular basis.never speak like a Madeiran’, I still don’t
The British government at some stage realised that itspeak the language very well and I am now realising
was necessary to do something to help these peoplethat those comments were absolutely spot on.
integrate into society, of course much too late, butHowever, I will add that I am learning and progressing
at least it was something.very slowly, and am able to have some mostly one
So by the late 90’s, I could pass by immigrantsway conversations with the locals, and I can feel
who had access to resources in education, the healthsome friendships blossoming, partly thanks to that
service, and the welfare and benefits systems, butgreat leveller called ‘football’, having ditched
by enlarge they still kept all their life activities withinmy English allegiances for clubs at both club and
their own families and ethnic groupings. Probably thenational levels. My website at madeira 4u will tell you
exception was in the workplace where through racialsome of the difficulties us Portuguese students face.
discrimination legislation different groups were forcedUnlike the British Government (albeit for selfish
to mingle and liaise, whether through workingreasons) the Madeiran government does nothing to
together or through a business to customer interface.encourage the mere existence of foreigners on its
Fine, but the integration plans just never succeeded,soil, other than to spend money and pay tax. Aside
and with certain ethnic groups the barriers tofrom its EU obligations that it cannot escape
friendship grew instead of shrinking, partly throughundetected, it provides nothing special for foreigners
traits and trends in crime attribution and sociabilitywhatsoever. We don’t have our gas bills available
issues, and also partly through the fact that many UKin 22 languages; we have to struggle to do our tax
taxpayers perceived the immigrants as actuallyreturns with requests for help ignored (which is a
having better resources and benefits than theygood reason why many of the immigrants living on
themselves had and were paying for, as well as newMadeira have never filed a tax return). We don’t
legislation to protect them from any unpleasant lifeget schooling laid on to help us learn the language, we
experiences which in itself was perceived as racism.don’t get offered jobs because the Madeiran
Whether these are valid issues that hamper socialemployers only employ their own kind, and if there
integration is not really the issue here. The issue isare any racial discrimination laws nobody here is
that given equality in every respect, is it reallyaware of them.
possible to coerce people to come together as oneThe people of Madeira are mostly kind and friendly,
race?and I can walk around any time of day or night
By the early part of the new millennium, politiciansknowing I am safe, and should I suffer a heart
were becoming openly more concerned about theattack on the street someone will arrive very quickly
issues or integration, or rather ‘nonto help me. The Madeirans by enlarge are deeply
integration’, and what is obvious to me now butcatholic with many regular church goers; however,
was just a suspicion at the time, is that they reallylike all religions, the rules are there to guide other
don’t understand the complexity of the issuespeople and rarely apply to oneself. The trouble with
and the difficulty involved, probably through havingbeing a foreigner is that it does imply a certain
never been in the same situation themselves andfinancial affluence whether it’s true or not, and it
certainly through not asking the people being askedis rather sad that some shops, bars, taxis, hotels and
to integrate about the difficulties. Moreover, politiciansother businesses will see you as a tourist, ready to
want integration to happen for different reasons thanbe short measured, overcharged, and underchanged.
if the people want it to happen, namely in that itEven the mosquitoes prefer my white soft skin to
reduces social problems, government expenditure atthat of the locals, whilst normally quiet dogs who let
local and national levels, unemployment and crime, andlocals past without bother, bark at me from one end
that’s just for starters.of the street to another, and even the stray cats I
OK, so now it’s happened to me, and the shoefeed run a mile if I get too close.
is on the other foot.I now accept that I can never fully integrate into the
In 2003 I went to live on Madeira Island, part ofsociety that I choose to live amongst, but I can
Portugal, a few hundred miles of the west coast ofkeep trying to make inroads if I make the effort,
Morocco, isolated in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean.and that takes me back to the beginning of this
I have not lived there all the time, and so I have stillaccount, reinforcing my now firm belief that if you
had plenty of time with my own people.cannot integrate people who want to integrate, what
Now the difference between me and the situation Ichance do you stand with those who show no
have already described is quite different, as I knew Iinterest in blending into the alien society in which they
would be pretty much alone, living in a small townlive. Add to that the point that in most societies it
(about 5,000 people) with very few of them able towould be near impossible to get two different
speak any English … my one and only language skill.cultures to a point where they could say they had
There would be a few English speaking expats, whoequality in all respects, as religion, political bias, and
might pressure a friendship on you under the umbrellapersonal and family beliefs, to name just a few, are
of ‘us and them’ and the ‘we Brits stickhuge stumbling blocks
together’ syndromes, when you probablyAnd maybe even more relevant is the fact that you
wouldn’t normally have anything to do with themcan’t teach or force a feeling of trust and
even if they lived next door back home.respect on someone, when they have difficulty
You can easily identify them, as when talking abouttrusting and respecting those around them, and
anything to do with the Madeira, they refer tothat’s exactly what a culture barrier does.
‘them’ rather than ‘we’, and